|
ARTICLES ANTHROPOLOGICAL
REFLECTIONS ON IMAGING OF WOMEN IN FOLKART AND FOLKLORE - AN ANALYSIS OF HIMACHAL
PRADESH RICHA In Himachal Pradesh the gender
biases in agricultural practices and attitudes of people are influenced greatly
by imaging in religion, folk literature and folk art. A majority of the population
lives in rural areas and agriculture is the main occupation. Agriculture continues
to remain of a sustenance type and even food security for the whole year through
has not been achieved. Gender differences are very subtly defined in the state
rendering women to wield a lot of responsibility but have limited rights in property
etc. The aim of this paper is to analyze the reasons for the slow pace of development
in the state, which are trapped in the state's anthropological background. The
paper further identifies that women who make significant contributions to family
and community in Himachal hold the key to bringing about change in the development
scenario and the traditional belief base needs to be stirred to make the people
realize that destiny is not entirely chance and that bringing about development
requires consistent efforts, the deconstruction of various myths and the reconstruction
of images which define gender roles.
Women in Himachal hold the key to
much of its development and ecological upliftment. While reason attributes their
many contributions to the circumstances of a hill economy, the attitudes of women
and other towards them are rooted in religion and folk culture. Himachal Pradesh
situated in the north-west part of India, right in the lap of the Himalayan ranges
(Joshi 1984) shares its international boundary with Tibet and China in the east
and is bounded by the states of Jammu and Kashmir in the north, Uttaranchal in
the south-east, Haryana in the south and Punjab in the west and south-west. It
covers an area of 55,673 square kms and accommodates almost 68 lakh persons. The
economy of Himachal Pradesh is mainly dependent on agriculture and is allied activities.
The agriculture production in the state still depends on timely rainfall and weather
conditions.
The Pahari School of art emerging from Himachal throws light
on the belief systems prevailing in the state. A painting ascribed to the court
of Mandi and dated back to the period, 1700-1725 is an image of Sadashiva, Shiva
is iconographed as having five heads, four facing in different directions and
the fifth notionally invisible, embedded in his matted locks and gazing heaven
ward (Fisher and Goswamy 1977). Sadashiva sits cross-legged on an elephant skin
and holds in his five right hands the emblems and weapons associated with him,
a trident, a tabor drum, a skull bowl with a hair lock, a held up sword and a
serpent. To this image the painter adds an element of surprise by placing in Sadashiva's
five arms on the left side proper emblems that are the cognizance of Vishnu- the
mace, the conch, the discus, and the lotus. In the fifth hand he adds a shield,
which hints at the presence of Shiva's consort, Parvati. A presence reinforced
by the unexpected appearance of a tiger, Parvati's vehicle. This is a syncretistic
image and very subtly suggests the rising impact of Vaishnavism in a traditionally
Shaiv and Shakt society. Vishnu and Shiv are two gods belonging to the Trinity
in Hindu philosophy. The Vaishnav tradition replaced the Shaiv tradition in Himachal
in phases. These movement are understood as reformist. The Shaiv tradition or
Shiv was associated with the worship of Shakti, the mother goddess and the worship
of the phallic, the tradition of Vishnu replaced this and placed society into
strict patriarchal and hierarchal order.
One of the earliest paintings
discovered in the hills and preserved in the Himachal Pradesh State Museum, Shimla
belongs to the Devi Mahatmya series. It is the picture of the goddess shown as
'Svadhinapatika nayika', she whose lover is wholly under her control. The painter
renders here no great deed of the goddess and no scene in which she engages the
demonic forces. Instead he shows a young woman, seated on a cushioned stool, holding
a full blown lotus in her left hand and gazing ahead of her while a man kneels
on the ground in front of her, humbly taking her left foot into his hands in a
gesture of utter submission and homage. With the simplest of means, the painter
conjures up a vision of female beauty and submission to it. While art was the
exclusive resort of a few, patronized by the kings in the hills, it is evident
that deification of the woman in all forms was popular and emerged from the society
being primarily agricultural. That deification was a continues process and every
aspect of femininity was deified and that the woman was also used to defend caste
and patriarchy, apart from representing wealth, knowledge, power and beauty is
evident from the following stories and legends from Himachal.(Ranjan and Jasta
1980).
A Popular folk theater in Chamba district narrates the story of
Suhi, a princess married into the Chamba royal family. The king of Chamba had
built a canal, but water would not flow in it. It was divined that the cause was
the curse of a god who could be appeased by sacrifice of a person dearest and
closest to the king. The queen and the prince offered to give their life for the
cause but the king was not ready to loose them. The next best choice was Suhi,
the daughter-in-law. She had just given birth to a son, who was feeding on her
milk and was reluctant to be the victim. Her pleas remained unheeded and she was
offered to the god and was buried alive in the canal embankment. It is believed
that the water flowed in the canal after the sacrifice, as the gods were satisfied.
The spirit of the pathetic princess was restless. She pinned for her child. Her
ghost would haunt the palace. A temple was built for her and an annual fair is
organized to keep alive the memory of her sacrifice. This folk play still played
in Chamba and other parts of Himachal shows how the society is seeped in superstitions
and how women continue to be the willing or un-willing victims of such superstitions.
As in a lot of other societies in Himachal too the elder women play a significant
role encouraging and perpetuating superstitions. Caste is another
very significant factor in Himachal. A popular folklore in Himachal is the story
of Durga, the beautiful daughter of a rich thakur(chieftain). Her father's biggest
aspiration was to own a house of dimensions and designs never heard or seen of
before. He engaged a thavi (master craftsman), widely known for his exquisite
woodwork. After years of unremitting labour, the craftsman built for him his house
of dreams. The thakur was immensely pleased and told the thavi to ask for anything
he desired as his fees. He was shocked when the thavi asked for his daughter's
hand in marriage. He drew his sword, but Durga stepped forward bid her folks farewell
and asked the craftsman to take her along. The bridal party stopped for the night
at the bank of a rivulet. Durga went to the rivulet, early morning apparently
for a wash and jumped into the swift current of the stream. Before the thavi could
touch her she ended her life. Durga is revered both for keeping the world of her
father and for not giving herself to a man of lower caste. Her image is installed
in a shrine dedicated to her. Another tragic tale is that of Renuka, a subject
of many legends in the Puranas. Himalaya has its own version, almost an eyewitness
account of events leading to her self willed end. She was a kshatriya princess
married to the saint Jamadgni. She had a sister Banika who was married to the
powerful king Sahasrabahu. Once Jamadgni planned to perform a mahayajna and invited
sages and princes to grace the occasion, but he left Sahasrabahu out. Banika approached
her sister to persuade Jamadgni to invite her husband also. Renuka pleaded with
Jamadgni to accede to her sister's requests. Much against his will Jamadgni sent
the invitation. He also borrowed the celestial cow, Kamadhenu from Indra for the
duration of the yajna. Sahasrabahu was intrigued by the lavish hospitality he
received. As a parting gift, he demanded the cow, which had provided Jamadgni
with everything. Jamadgni refused and managed to return Kamadhenu to Indra. Slighted,
Sahasrabahu killed Jamadgni. Renuka blamed herself for the tragedy and jumped
into a lake and dissolved in it. This lake in Sirmour is known as Renukasaar.
Renuka was the mother of Parshuram who is also associated with the tradition of
the Vishnu. It is evidenced through folk tales in Himachal that Parshuram initially
accepted himself as belonging to the 'Kshatriya (warrior) caste as his mother
was a Kshatriya princess. Later he came to think that the Kshatriyas were evil
and undertook to rid the world of them. He assumed his father's caste (Brahman)
and advocated indirectly the end of inter-caste marriages.
Symbolic imagery
has often been used in Himachal to maintain the distinctiveness of their society
while at the same time drawing upon deities from the Hindu pantheon. Features
associated with some goddesses such as self sacrifice and benevolence in Sita,
the heroine of the Ramayan, are retained in folk literature but added to these
are the virtues of a bold woman who goes alone to fetch cold water for her husband
from the deeps of the forests (Jasta, 1974). Fetching water and looking after
livestock are tasks performed primarily by women in Himachal. Towards the east,
where the Pir Panjal mountain range tapers down to the Sutlej bed, there are lush
green forests and pastures, favorite of shepherds and cowherds. A bold young maiden
used to take her cattle here for grazing. One day, a ferocious bear made a frontal
attack on her, lacerated her face and left her dead in a pool of blood. A temple
was built to her and is still there in the middle of the forest with an image
of the girl with a bruised face. Known as Sharai Devi, she is supposed to be a
very powerful goddess who fulfills all her devotees' wishes.
Another legend
in Himachal is about lord Shiva lamenting his wife Sati's death. Shiva was carrying
the dead body of Sati on his shoulders to the high Himalayas and the world was
burning from his wrath and grief. Vishnu, at the bidding of the other gods, sneaked
along behind Shiva. He kept cutting off parts of Sati's body in order to that
the fires of dissolution get expelled. The breasts of Sati fell at Hatkoti in
Jubbal in Shimla district. A temple was built on the spot and called the temple
of Hateshwari. People from distant parts of India visit the shrine especially
on the first day of spring and during the nine days of 'navratras' in October.
In this temple there is an image of the goddess of breasts made of eight metals.
The most interesting feature of the rare image is the huge copper vessel, which
is chained to one of the hands of the Ganesha, the god of initiation, near her
image. It is believed that once the temple priest of Hateshwari was sleeping in
the temple compound. Outside it was raining torrentially and the river close-by
was flooding. The priest in his sleep heard a continuous resounding sound. He
woke up to find two big vessels moving in unison in the water near the bank. He
jumped into the water, grabbed the copper vessels and managed to drag them to
the shore. He brought them to the temple and offered them to the divine Mother.
The vessels were kept on either side of the door to the temple where the priest
kept them filled with food and fruits for distribution to the worshippers. After
a few days it rained heavily again and waters swelled. The priest woke up hearing
the same sounds and saw the vessels floating in the river. He got hold of one
but the other was carried deep into the stream by the waves. The priest chained
the other vessels to the hands of an image of Ganesha with a stout iron chain.
The local women believe if they ever see the missing vessel as they sow seed in
the knee-deep waters of the rice fields, they can look forward to a bountiful
harvest (Ranjan & Jasta, 1980). The symbolism of "kalasa" with initiation
and fertility is here firmly established. In the Satapatha Brahmana, (XIII.8.3.3)
ghata or kumbha meaning jar is equated with the womb of the mother Goddess. The
initiation of occasions and festivals with a jar filled with water is common.
The symbolism of kumbha to the womb is clear, as initiation is also a rebirth.
The Kathasaritsagar identifies kumbha with uterus. This explains why the Navaratra
or the nine-day fertility festival begins every year on the first Asvina by ghatasthapana
or establishing of a fertility jar.
A lot of symbolism is maintained in
the agricultural practices sometimes even when reason and circumstances forbid.
A prominent agricultural myth in Himachal is that women are not allowed to plough
the fields though women do almost everything else in the fields. Where the sons
have migrated in Himachal to seek jobs in urban areas or to join the armed forces
the land is either given away to the poorer households to cultivate with half
of its produce to keep as their own (tenancy) or the family keeps the field uncultivated,
waiting for the sons to return. The myth perhaps draws from that the earth is
taken as symbolic of the female embryo and the plough as the symbolic of the phallyx.
In the Mahabharat (III.141) mother earth is brought in relation to Vishnu and
in course of time she becomes his consort. It is said that mother Earth sank down
hundred yojanas (unit of measurement) burdened with the pressure of population.
She sought the protection of Vishnu who assuming the form of a boar restored her
to her position (Singh 1993). The concept of the king or the master of the household
taking upon himself to plough the land during times of drought perhaps emerged
during the period of the growing impact of the Vaishnav tradition as earth was
understood to be the second spouse of Vishnu and the king under the Vaishnav tradition
was seen as an incarnation of Vishnu himself.
In the epic Ramayana, Sita
is portrayed as having been waded out of a field, the king Janak of Mithila, now
in Bihar, undertook to plough himself to end drought in his kingdom. The drought
ended subsequently and Janak adopted Sita as his daughter. Himachal Pradesh also
has a long history of droughts. The availability of water for agriculture is believed
to be a result of divine inspiration. Rain is believed to be a result of the gods
being satisfied with the people and the condition of no rains or excessive rains
is believed to be the result of the wrath of gods. Evidences of people having
dug out water from the ground exist but are few. Some of these evidences have
also got trapped in legends and are explained as divinely inspired. A mythical
evidence comes from Mandi district where Arjun's arrow is supposed to have dug
out water from the ground to quench his mother Kunti's thirst. The 'saar' (pond)
is called "Kunt Bayo" after Kunti. Another instance is from Gagret in
Una district where lord Shiv is believed to have created water in the thick of
forest to hide in. The place is known as "Shiv Bowdi". Hence most instances
of water having been found are explained mythologically.
As the above examples
show the two Indian epics Ramayana and Mahabharata are embedded in the psyche
of Himachal Pradesh. Sita, the main female character in the Ramayana serves as
a role model for most adolescent girls and married women in the state. A living
evidence of overwhelming correspondence between Vedic literature and Himalayan
folk tradition exists. In the Vedas, Sita is purely an agricultural deity and
Sita means the furrow, which bears crops for mankind. The word Ram (Later came
to be understood as an incarnation of Vishnu) means the act of ploughing and also
that of sexual intercourse (Dange 1979; Dandekar 1979; Bhattacharya 1996). Allusions
to that "Prithvi" or earth must always endure and suffer the atrocities
of nature and the will of the Gods as Sita did as the daughter of Prithvi are
common in Himachal. The belief system in the state is typified by an attitude
or reconciliation to the twists and turns of fate, co-existing with a disproportionate
belief in village deities and other Gods and Goddesses. Inherent in the thought,
lie the seeds of the belief that there are no options other than hoping for better
days as Sita did, while waiting for her reconciliation with Ram.
Since
ancient times in Himachal, one particular deity presides within a certain geographical
space although there may be more than one god in an area (Sharma 1990). The chief
deities dominate social and cultural intercourse and set the social calendar of
the festival; forecast weather, crop, disease and well-being; answer individual
queries; hex opponents of devotees and interact in all facets of village life.
It is a standard practice for the god to visit relatives and friends in other
villages and even for specific households to invite them. On such occasion a member
of each household in their domain is obliged to accompany them. It is believed
that those households that do not send a representative with the 'devta's' (deity's)
retinue are punished by crop failure or illness or in some other way by divinity.
The temple committee also charges a fine from them. There is no denying the fact
that much good came during the medieval times by vesting and centralizing authority
in a deity. The head of a family or village group was often the ancestral deity
and provided a bond of union between those who acknowledged its jurisdiction.
The temple, normally owned land granted by rulers and tenanted by a community.
In some cases they became the tenants of the devtas. Sometimes if a village migrated
they took their devta with them. Often the catchment area from where the village
derived its water source was the forest of the deity. When a party broke away
from the parent settlement taking with it an emblem of the deity, in time this
got regarded as a separate deity but the memory of a common origin preserved in
the fiction. Forests above village settlements were carefully preserved since
spring water associated with them was considered crucial. It was assigned sanctity
as the devta's sacred forest. In the Shimla region groves of deodar were held
sacred and belonged to the village devta. Felling of these trees was banned, except
with the permission of the devta. Temple groves varied in extent from a few trees
to forests of several acres and constituted the traditional method of forest preservation.
(Cleghorn 1864). While the deities initially encouraged conservation of forests,
felling of trees has now become common during temple festivals, marriages and
funerals and the deities sanction is fully provided through his oracles or mouthpieces.
In the tribal areas in Himachal a mixed influence of Buddhism and the village
deity faith exists. The temple of the deity and of Buddh or/and Padmasambhav,
the perpetrator of the Tantric form of Buddhism are found constructed in the same
complex (Bagchi 1939; Raha 1979). While in some areas it is the Shaiv tradition
and worship co-existing with Buddhism in most areas the Vaishnav tradition prevails.
Vishnu is also the most significant deity in the upper caste villages. The mother
goddess is also worshipped in Himachal and in different areas different localized
versions of her are associated with either the Shaiv or the Vaishnav tradition.
Nirmal Kumar Bose had pointed out that India had a stratarchy of gods, based on
the caste system (Nandy, 1977). The higher the status of a deity, the less directly
helpful and relevant the deity is in everyday life. For instance Indra, the king
of gods has a high status in the pantheon, but is not relevant in our day-to-day
existence or survival. The Hindu temples within the precincts of most Buddhist
temples are a corollary to the same principle. The devotees see the Buddhist divinity
as too austere and for everyday purposes want to deal with the more amenable lower
ranked deities.
The creation of gods and goddesses and myths is the result
of a situation of necessity. Their undoing is a movement from the situation of
necessity to the situation of freedom. Dr Ashis Nandy says that gods and goddesses
enter human life to provide a quasi-human, sacral presence, to balance the powerful
forces of desacralization in human relationships, vocations and nature. Spirituality
is party a gift of mortality; it is associated more with the mortals than with
the gods, who are usually seen to have a streak of hedonism. Second, gods can
also be vulnerable and require the help of humans for fighting demons or other
gods. The gods and goddesses in Himachal are part and parcel of the day to day
routine and it seems are difficult to do away with.
The concept of Virah
or separation is very common in folk songs in Himachal demonstrating that migration
of men has been a common phenomenon. While in some cases migration resulted in
agricultural fields being rendered fallow there are also evidences of migration
promoting social mobility and resulting in economic independence and relative
autonomy of women. It has resulted in giving women more control over their earnings
or at least, greater participation in family decisions. Another distinctive feature
is a high level of female labour-force participation. With a high female work
participation rate of 34.81% Himachal is second only to Mizoram where a very high
female work participation rate of 43.52% exists. Himachal is way ahead of all
the other north Indian states (Drez & Sen, 1995). This feature, in turn, can
be related to specific aspects of the hill economy. A basic contrast can be drawn
between the densely populated, land-scarce, surplus-labour economy of the Gangetic
plain, and the hill economy where the scarcity of land and other natural resources
is less pronounced. In the former, women tend to be confined to the household,
though their labour power is mobilized at time of peak agricultural activity such
as harvest seasons. In the hill economy, where natural resources such as forests
and pastures (if no cultivable land) are relatively abundant, there is greater
scope for labour absorption and women's labour power tends to be mobilized on
a larger scale.
Marriage practices are another distinctive feature of Himachal's
society. These have an important bearing on schooling decisions, since marriage
is a major focus of the upbringing of daughters in north India. Marriage practices
in north India typically include a dowry being paid by the bride's family; after
marriage, a woman leaving her own family to join her husband's, often in a distant
village and women being expected to marry men of a higher status, e.g., in terms
of educational qualification. These patriarchal norms, imparted by the ideology
of kanyadaan (giving a daughter away in marriage is considered a religious duty)
create profound asymmetries between the marriage of a son and that of a daughter,
which get reflected in their respective upbringings. In Himachal Pradesh, however,
these norms tend to be relatively flexible. For instance though dowry is still
a common practice it takes a less rigid form than in other parts of the northern
region. Bride price is also common, and was till some time ago more widespread
than dowry. Similarly, the alienation of a married woman from her natal home is
less drastic in Himachal Pradesh than elsewhere in north India. The notion of
hierarchy between in-laws (with the groom's family occupying the higher position)
is also relatively weak in Himachal Pradesh (Dreze & Khera, 1999). As with
female labour force participation, there are many ways in which the more symmetric
nature of marriage practices in Himachal Pradesh is likely to have a positive
influence on girls' schooling. Elsewhere in north India, parents often feel that
they have little stake in educating girls, since daughters are expected to leave
the family after marriage. The fact that Himachal's daughters need not "marry
up" reliance's parents of the possible concern that a well-educated daughter
may be difficult to marry (The Probe Team, 1999).
The rural woman in Himachal
Pradesh has limited time and hence her space gets limited also. The onslaughts
on her time and space are subtle but numerous. Her day starts and ends with filling
water for the household, tending to livestock, working on the fields and attending
to all other household chores. A high preference for male off springs still exists
and the fertility rate in Himachal remains high at 2.97, though it is less than
the all India average of 3.39 (Murthi, et al., 1995). Women have limited rights
in landed property. Separation and divorce are common among the tribal societies
and poor rural families in Himachal. Normally the Panchayats and the tribal communities
themselves take decisions regarding divorce or separation. Women are given little
or no compensation. The main reason why her natal family accepts her back is perhaps
that, as an extra hand to work on the fields she is an asset to the family. Another
reason is that the community ordains that the girl is taken back in her natal
house and a small piece of land is considered to be hers and is put in her name.
In Himachal Pradesh both polyandry and polygamy exist. In Kinnaur district and
parts of Shimla district there is polyandry, one wife to all the brothers in a
household. The purpose of the tradition was to prevent fragmentation of holdings
and it has survived since ancient days. In the course of discussions with women
it emerged that women, especially the older women defended this tradition. They
insisted that as in other parts of Himachal their area does not have folk songs
where the theme of women's separation from their husbands or lovers is prominent.
The younger women are skeptical. They say that they are scared they have preferences
or are likely to have if they are not already married, that will show leading
to frustration within the family. They also say that the custom does not stop
individual men from getting second wives and starting to live with them separately.
Thus though property and other rights are vested in the common wife there are
problems and the arrangement does not always buy emotional security for her.
In
cases of polygamy men usually marry when their desire for a male offspring is
not fulfilled from the first wife or if they are childless. There are also numerous
instances of migrated men taking on second wives. In Himachal however the practice
of marrying off daughters too soon does not exist and the practice of late marriage
exists among both men and women. A good number of women take a conscious decision
of remaining single. Visiting temples and going to attend weddings or mourning
funerals are the only real outings for women and they look forward to it. In spite
of the very patriarchal connotations that the temple has the women enjoy going
to temples and see it as liberating rather than an experience restricting their
space. Adolescent girls can sometimes be seen hanging around ponds and springs,
which they obviously don't view as claustrophobic symbols of space. Elopement
is happening in the case of inter-caste marriage though it is not very common.
Mostly the marriage is not ever given parental sanction and the couple needs to
have the necessary ability to provide for their life together in order that these
marriages become successful.
Ecological problems are increasing in Himachal
with water and drought problem becoming intense for parts of the year and floods
and heavy rains during the monsoons resulting in heavy losses to crop. Floods
and cloudbursts have been leading also to loss of life and property in the districts
of Chamba, Kinnaur and Shimla. The reasons are many varying from melting of major
glaciers in Lahaul Spiti, Kinnaur and Chamba districts to heavy grazing pressure
resulting in loss of support area and forest cover in parts of Himachal. These
factors further make life difficult for women.
Conclusions
Roland
Barthes asks, 'What is characteristic of myth?' and answers: 'To transform a meaning
into form.' Myths are stories that mediate in this way between the known and unknown.
(Barthes 1970). Claude Levi-Strauss wittily de-mythologizes myth as a genre between
a fairy tale and a detective story. Not knowing how certain events or things happened
something satisfying, if not the answer, can be invented. Myth was the mystery
plus the fantasy -gods, anthro-pomorphized animals and birds, chimera, phantasmagorical
creatures-that posits out of the imagination some sort of explanation for the
mystery. Humans and their fellow creatures were the materiality of the story,
but as Nikos Kazantzakis once wrote, 'art is the representation not of the body
but of the forces which created the body. 'As Nadine Gordimer, the Nobel Laureate
said there are many proven explanations for natural phenomena now; and there are
new questions arising out of some of the answers. For this reason, the genre of
myth has never been entirely abandoned, although we are inclined to think of it
as archaic. If it dwindled to the children's bend time tales in some societies,
in parts of the world protected by forests or deserts from international mega
culture it has continued, alive, to offer art as a system of mediation between
the individual and existence.
It is in Dharamshala in Himachal Pradesh
that the Dalai Lama, the spiritual head of Tibet has based himself and is running
the Tibetan government in exile silently protesting the Chinese aggression in
Tibet. Peace and co-existence are inherent in the spirit of Himachal. But inherent
also are a strong sense of reconciliation and too much of religion. The problem
in most districts of Himachal is not that of a change of modernization, which
social psychologists describe as a ripping apart of cultural and geographical
home-lands and an ongoing turbulence, which invariably leads to an alienating
sense of loss and helplessness. The problem is more that of an undying and unwavering
faith in ancient beliefs and legends, a confident resilience honed on years and
years of forever scraping the past. A political movement is much needed in Himachal,
which questions the very existence of the myths and the presence of the numerous
deities in the state. The movement should not be of the nature of improved science
and technology being introduced, as results have been that the local culture gets
entirely lost. Demonstration effect has been witnessed in Himachal to bring about
the negative impacts of the outside culture while retaining the bad impacts of
ones' own and no proper fusion or synthesis of cultures has even been achieved.
Any movement introduced only with outside influence gets likely to treat the natives
as heathens. Himachal waits for divine inspiration in vain believing that it will
not fail them in the end after having established firmly in its psyche that it
has never failed them in the past. The women are victim of the same psychology
and suffer twice as much as men. Enterprise is limited in the state and in the
same of generating employment a much inflected and artificial tertiary sector
has resulted, with a very high preference for government jobs existing in the
state.
The conflict between feminism and multiculturalism has emerged before
in the debates over female infanticide and genital mutilation in the Third World,
and even on domestic matters such as the use of cultural difference as a legal
defense for immigrant men who kill adulterous wives or force their underage daughters
into marriage.
In Himachal Pradesh too the conflict is real as the women
actively defend their traditional base. Only women who have suffered drastically
the ills of the system wake up to its realities and realize that a diversion from
the existing pattern is required. Sometimes these women too because of the hardships
their own life has ordained find it hard to come up to the forefront as they come
to understand themselves as social rejects. Women in Himachal have never really
considered that the myths that dominate their life and the psyche of the state
need to be deconstructed or reconstructed. It is only from Mandi district in Himachal
that a few evidences of women having undertaken to plough the farms themselves
in the absence of men have come. On one hand Himachal's women want to be as brave
as Sharai who ventured alone into the thicks of the jungles, on the other hand
they worship Suhi and Durga for their respective sacrifices and Renuka for refusing
to live after her husband was killed. The folk songs in Himachal echo with the
thoughts and incidences of stranded loves, ravaged fates, despaired memories and
extreme sacrifices. With heavy onslaughts on their time and heavy workload, life
on the shores and enjoyment of nature, even while they live in the midst of shores
and hills, exists for Himachal's women only at the level of dreams.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Acknowledgements
are due to Prof. Qureshi who inspite of his extremely busy schedule, made useful
comments and helped me improve it. I am grateful to all those women in Himachal
who inspired me to conduct this sort of work amongst them. Thanks are also due
to my mother for accompanying me during the time of field work. References
Bagchi,
P.C 1939. Studies in Tantras, Calcutta, University of Calcutta Press Barthes,
Richard 1970. S/Z Paris, Seuil Bhattacharya, N. N. 1996 Earth and Woman, A
study in the Cults and rituals of Fertility. In Ancient Indian Rituals and
Their Social Context. Delhi: Manohar. Cleghorn, H.F. 1864. Report upon the
Forest of Punjab and the Western Himalayas. Roorkee. Dandekar, R.N. 1979.
Vedic Mythological Tracts, Selected Writings, Vol 1, pp 9-16 & 36-38.
Delhi: Ajanta Publishers. Dange, S.A. 1979. Sexual Symbolism from the Vedic
Ritual. Delhi, Ajanta Publishers. Dreze, Jean and Khera, Reetika 1999.
Crime, Gender and Society in India. Working Paper 64, Centre for Development
Economics at the Delhi School of Economics. Dreze, Jean, and Sen, Amartya 1995.
India: Economic Development and Social Opportunity, New Delhi, Oxford University
Press. Fischer, E and Goswami, 1997. Pahari Masters. Delhi, Oxford India B.N.
Press. Gordimer Nadine 1991. Writing and Being. Nobel Lecture organized by
the Nobel Foundation Jasta, H.R. (ed.) 1974. Pahari Lok Ramayan. Shimla,
Himachal Pradesh Academy of Language, Art and Culture. Joshi, K.L. 1984.
Geography of Himachal Pradesh, New Delhi, National Book Trust. Kazantzakis,
Nikos. 1965 Report to Greco. Translation by Peter A. Bien, 150 & 181-182.
New York, Bantam Books Inc. Murthi, M., Guio, A. C., and Dreze, J. P. 1995.
Mortality, Fertility and Gender Bias in India: A District Level Analysis.'
Population and Development Review 21. Nandy Ashis. 1997. Facing Extermination,
A Report on the Present State of the Gods and Goddesses in South Asia. Manushi
99: 5-18. Raha, M.K. 1979. Stratification and Religion in a Himalayan Society.'
In Himalayan Anthropology: The Indo-Tibetan Interface, ed. James F. Fisher.
Moutine, TX: Aldine. Ranjan, S.P. & Jasta, H.R. 1980. Folk Tales of Himachal
Pradesh. U.K., Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan. Sharma, B. R. 1990. The Institution
of the Village Gods in the western Himalayas. In N.K. Rustomji and Charles
Ramble, Himalayan Environment and Culture, Shimla, Indian Institute of Advanced
Studies. Singh K.S (ed.) 1993. Mahabharat in the Tribal and Folk Traditions
of India, Shimla, Indian Institute of Advanced Studies. Strauss, Claude
Levi 1963. Structural Anthropology, New York, Basic Books. The PROBE Team.
1999, Public Report on Basic Education in India. New Delhi, Oxford University
Press.
|